Strange Estrangement

Estrangement is defined as “a breakdown in a relationship, such as a relationship with a spouse or family member, where there is no longer any communication, or communication has become hostile, and the individuals lead separate lives.”

And these breakdowns in family relationships are more common than you might think.
“One US study of more than 2,000 mother-child pairs found that 10% of mothers were currently estranged from at least one adult child.” And the percentage of people who had experienced family estrangement was as “high as 40%,” which makes estrangement “almost as common as divorce.” 1

No matter how wealthy or well-known, no one is immune to the problem. The English actor Anthony Hopkins admitted that he has “barely spoken with his daughter in two decades.” And personalities like Meghan Markle have brought attention to the topic with her much publicized estrangement from her father.

The reasons for an estrangement can be complex, but basically it is when one individual severs all contact with a person or persons, who are viewed as the source of real or imagined harm and/or seen as a real or imagined threat to their well-being. And an estrangement will mean going forward that there will be limited opportunities to recover or repair the relationship because there is no communication. Estrangements can go on for months, years or a lifetime.

And even in my small orbit of friends and family, I have seen these breakdowns.

A friend in the US came from a large, Irish-Catholic family of eight children. One day she revealed that she didn’t speak to a few of her siblings. She was a larger than life character, who lived with passion and gusto. Thinking about she and her seven siblings in one room, I imagined the din would have been the equivalent of a large audience yelling during a bloody boxing match combined with a choir aggressively singing the Hallelujah chorus! I never asked for details but I got the impression the schism came from political differences.

Another family had a serious disagreement because of a scheduling conflict for a wedding, resulting in a huge rupture. The feud has been going on for years and it’s unlikely to end because there isn’t a real solution other than both sides agreeing to put the problem aside and begin again. But some of the things said were so offensive and some actions so egregious, this simply may not be possible—apologies may never be sufficient and like any ‘strange’ estrangement, it may never be healed.

Sibling jealousy and deep psychological problems resulted in another family breakdown that I have witnessed. It would take a monumental emotional shift on the part of the person who has chosen estrangement to repair the situation because it is easier for them to blame others than take responsibility for their actions. This issue has been going on for years.

When faced with an estrangement, it’s recommended to speak to a therapist. But their professional advice might surprise you. One therapist advised his clients not to waste any precious time trying to solve the problem. In his experience, apparently, it didn’t help and the best choice for those people who are shunned was to live in the present and to “get on with their life.” His advice freed the clients from feeling guilty about their inability to find a solution, and acknowledged that individuals who chose estrangement as a response to problems are not really interested in or equipped to face the serious issues that started the problem in the first place. The best advice for anyone who has been on the receiving end of a family estrangement is to go forward and live your best life even in an estranged world.

1 Christine Ro, ‘The Truth About Family Estrangement,’ https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20190328-family-estrangement-causes, BBC, 2019. 8 March 2025.

Picture of Joyce Agee

Joyce Agee

Writing can magically transport us anywhere. My blog looks at the experiences of being an expat newcomer; life in a small town in regional Australia, and what the world looks like living ‘down under’.

SHARE

Related posts

Cat & Pigeons 

Recently, I was giving a talk about my book The Newcomer’s Dictionary at a local library. In conversation with one of the audience members, I discussed a potential issue that would cause some concerns for

Read More »

The Madness of Social Media

If anyone has ever has tried to solve a technical glitch related to Facebook (Meta), Instagram or another social media platform, you will know that the process to solve a problem can be so difficult

Read More »

Jane Again

The opportunity to reread a book seems a luxury. With all of the new books and limited time how do we justify it? On impulse, I borrowed a new paperback edition of Charlotte Bronte’s Jane

Read More »

On Friendship

Moving frequently growing up, childhood friendships were made and broken but not necessarily forgotten. I have vivid memories of a girl from first grade in Florence, Alabama who invited me over to spend the night

Read More »

Thanksgiving Thoughts

An Australian friend recently asked me about the significance of the Thanksgiving holiday in America. Living abroad, I am accustomed to people not understanding this holiday as it is uniquely American and does not have

Read More »

Tyranny of Distance

Numerous books for expats offer practical ideas to help bridge the distance from family and loved ones when people live in other countries. But let’s face it, the hardship of overcoming great distances is real

Read More »

Learning Leisure Activities 

We planned a glamorous two-day holiday on the coast of Victoria for my birthday, but instead of feeling like a holiday, it felt more like a trip to a comic Twilight Zone. Admittedly, our challenges

Read More »

Another Agee on Film 

James Rufus Agee (1909-1955), was the posthumous winner of the Pulitzer Prize for literature in 1958 for his autobiographical novel, A Death in the Family. He is our family’s most distinguished member and comes from

Read More »

Contains Tobacco Depictions

Accustomed as I am to the verbal tomfoolery of streaming services labeling, nevertheless, I was astonished to recently see a descriptor for The Bear, an American television series with drama, comedy and cooking set in

Read More »

Repatriation Penalty Phase

My reentry to the United States after living overseas for more than three decades was a trial by fire. Everything was familiar but everything had changed. I didn’t understand the professional scene, health care or

Read More »